Skip to content
Psychotherapy Notes
  • Exam Prep
    • California LMFT Clinical Exam Prep
    • California LMFT Law & Ethics Exam Prep
    • California LPCC Law & Ethics Exam Prep
    • California LCSW Law & Ethics Exam Prep
    • National MFT Exam Test Bank
  • CE Courses
    • California Law & Ethics for BBS Associates (AMFTs, APCCs, and ASWs) – 2023
    • Telehealth for California LMFTs, LPCCs, and LCSWs
  • Books
    • Basics of California Law for LMFTs, LPCCs, and LCSWs (10th ed)
    • Saving Psychotherapy
    • Preparing for the 2023 California MFT Law & Ethics Exam
    • Preparing for the 2023 California Clinical Social Work Law & Ethics Exam
  • Resources
  • Blog
    • Blog home
    • Psychology
    • Professional Counseling
    • Family therapy
    • Clinical social work
    • Law and ethics
    • Education
    • Employment
    • Licensure
    • Public policy

CSWE recommends all states pause use of social work licensing exams

January 12, 2023October 18, 2022 by Ben Caldwell

students studying for a test // photo by Matthew Henry, used under licenseFollowing the release of a horrifying report from the Association of Social Work Boards acknowledging significant racial disparities in license exam performance, the Council on Social Work Education (CSWE) has written to social work boards across the country urging them to pause the use of ASWB social work licensing exams.

The CSWE letter, which was partially published by the Illinois chapter of the National Association of Social Workers, includes four requests of US social work boards:

  1. Suspend use of ASWB social work licensing exams until recommendations can be made, based on evidence, to fix the inequities highlighted in the ASWB report.
  2. Grant all graduates of accredited social work programs appropriate licensure or pre-licensure status, without requiring an ASWB exam. In other words, use the degree as proof of adequate training. Notably, the CSWE letter here makes a hedged exception for the ASWB Clinical Exam, acknowledging the need for a “post-graduate process” to ensure competency at a clinical licensure level, while suggesting “further analysis of the [ASWB] descriptive data […] to identify possible issues.”
  3. Consider following the lead of the Illinois social work board, which removed the ASWB exam as a requirement for social work licensure earlier this year.
  4. “Consider decoupling the Interstate Compact, currently in development, from the ASWB licensure exam.”

If adopted, these would be major changes in the licensing process for social workers across the country. Currently, all states license Clinical Social Workers at the master’s degree level, while many but not all license Social Workers at the bachelor’s degree level. Social work licensing exams are a requirement for licensure as a social worker, alongside a qualifying degree and, for Clinical Social Workers, supervised experience.

A problem across mental health professions

The weaknesses in license exams are well-known — and are particularly salient when considering clinical exams for licensure. (Clinical exams focus on client care but do not actually resemble that care in any meaningful way. They can be distinguished from law and ethics exams, also known as jurisprudence exams, which focus on legal and ethical compliance and, in some cases, crisis intervention.) Clinical exams, across mental health professions, have never demonstrated their value. They do not appear to correlate in any meaningful way with the thing that they are supposed to measure: Safety for independent practice.

Exam developers have gradually backtracked even on the basic purpose of license exams, today suggesting that they are only one part of a multi-part process to establish that a person has an appropriate knowledge base in their field. This muddying of the waters only serves to limit exams’ accountability.

The controversy over the EPPP-2 in Psychology has only highlighted how clinical exams have become cash cows for the organizations that develop them, while limiting the racial diversity of the mental health professions. Both of those might be tolerable if the exams actually correlated with anything having to do with public safety. But they have never demonstrated such a correlation. They’re all cost, and no benefit. CSWE is well-justified in suggesting they be suspended or done away with entirely.

Share this:

  • Email
  • Tweet

Related

California BBS adds Telehealth CE requirement for everyone, new Law and Ethics CE requirement for Associates
What the BBS “one week notice” rule for supervisors signing hours means

📈 Trending 📈

  • Decoding counselor alphabet soup: LPC, LPCC, LMHC, and more
  • California sets new rules for therapists writing ESA letters
  • What's the difference between an MFT (or LMFT), an LPC (or LPCC), and an LCSW?
  • Therapists should not write Emotional Support Animal letters
  • Major changes are coming to California BBS supervision rules in 2022

📣 New Posts 📣

  • Write a letter to the editor: Drop the ASWB exams March 7, 2023
  • The mental health workforce shortage solution is right there February 14, 2023
  • The ASWB Clinical Exam reckoning has begun February 7, 2023
  • CareDash shuts down February 3, 2023
  • How to diagnose telehealth connection problems January 18, 2023
Ben Caldwell Labs

Psychotherapy Notes is the official blog of Ben Caldwell Labs

All content and images © Copyright 2009-2023 Ben Caldwell Labs unless otherwise noted.
Some images are used under Creative Commons licensing (information embedded).

Ben Caldwell Labs, the Ben Caldwell Labs logo, and Psychotherapy Notes are registered trademarks of Ben Caldwell Labs Inc.

The opinions expressed on posts on this site are solely those of the author.
While this blog does sometimes cover legal issues, unless otherwise noted authors are practicing clinicians and not attorneys.
Nothing here should be interpreted as legal advice, nor should it be considered a substitute for consulting with a qualified attorney.
  • Exam Prep
    • California LMFT Clinical Exam Prep
    • California LMFT Law & Ethics Exam Prep
    • California LPCC Law & Ethics Exam Prep
    • California LCSW Law & Ethics Exam Prep
    • National MFT Exam Test Bank
  • CE Courses
    • California Law & Ethics for BBS Associates (AMFTs, APCCs, and ASWs) – 2023
    • Telehealth for California LMFTs, LPCCs, and LCSWs
  • Books
    • Basics of California Law for LMFTs, LPCCs, and LCSWs (10th ed)
    • Saving Psychotherapy
    • Preparing for the 2023 California MFT Law & Ethics Exam
    • Preparing for the 2023 California Clinical Social Work Law & Ethics Exam
  • Resources
  • Blog
    • Blog home
    • Psychology
    • Professional Counseling
    • Family therapy
    • Clinical social work
    • Law and ethics
    • Education
    • Employment
    • Licensure
    • Public policy

Basics of California Law for LMFTs, LPCCs, and LCSWs – 10th ed

Basics of California Law for LMFTs, LPCCs, and LCSWs - 10th edition front cover (c) Copyright 2023 Ben Caldwell LabsTenth edition (2023). A concise, digestible summary of vital elements of state law for master’s level therapists and mental health professionals.